Opinions - Thursday, 2 April 2009
Two and a half cheers for a G20 triumph (The Times), Ask Not What Europe Can Do for You (Foreign Policy), Japanese Expert Criticizes US Wishful Thinking on Economic Crisis (Naked Capitalism), The Socialist Solution to the Crisis (Wall Street Journal), Geithner's Plan: Loopholes Galore (Business Week), The Quiet Coup (The Atlantic), The G20 has lost the plot (The Telegraph).
By Anatole Kaletsky
The Anglo-Saxon economies, galvanised by low interest rates, can be more optimistic than the eurozone and Japan.
Forget the stage-managed rows, walkouts and last-minute reconciliations, today's G20 summit will end in agreement, amity and mutual congratulation. The summit's success is preordained in two and a half ways.
First, it is a matter of simple arithmetic that today's meeting will be essentially a rubber-stamping ceremony for deals already done between the sherpas, the senior civil servants who have spent the past three months clearing the way to the summit for the G20 leaders. This can be stated with certainty because genuine negotiations will be impossible in the summit's four hours of business sessions. With 24 political leaders not known for their self-effacement all determined to have a say, the time allotted averages barely 11 minutes per speaker - and this calculation makes no allowance for the central bankers, finance ministers and international officials also in attendance, or the long and ornate soliloquies delivered on such occasions by Italian, Spanish and Latin American politicians.
Second, it is a matter of political certainty that all the leaders genuinely want to save the world from the present crisis. And none has any reason to obstruct the four different roads to salvation on the summit agenda. Everyone agrees on the need for monetary, fiscal and trade stimulus, to save failing banks with government support, to save failing countries with support from international institutions and to save global capitalism with reforms that restore faith in the financial system. (...)
Go to the source
Ask Not What Europe Can Do for You (Foreign Policy - U.S.)
By Stephen Sestanovich
For any U.S. president, the trick to dealing with Europe is to politely ignore its advice.
Barack Obama is in Europe this week, for meetings in which America's allies are likely to tell him that they can't contribute much more to the U.S. military campaign in Afghanistan, and don't want to re-float the world economy through government deficits. He shouldn't take it personally. And we shouldn't treat it as the end of the story.
For half a century and more, in good times and bad, European leaders have advised new American presidents not to bother them with big, risky, expensive Washington ideas. They almost always prefer the status quo -- or, at most, very incremental change. But, having said their piece, they then usually come around. (Sometimes -- very rarely, it has to be said -- they're right to begin with.)(...)
Go to the source
Japanese Expert Criticizes US Wishful Thinking on Economic Crisis (Naked Capitalism - The Net)
The George Santayana saying, "Those who cannot learn from history are doomed to repeat it," is so oft repeated as to verge on cliche. Yet the US variant of this syndrome is to be aware of history, then rationalize how it does not apply to us.
Japanese policy makers from the early days of the crisis have been saying in an uncharacteristically direct manner that the top priority is resolving nonperforming assets. Recapitalizing banks without taking this step is a mere palliative.
What is telling in this VoxEU account by Keiichiro Kobayashi is how the US and UK are going down the path of denial and expediency blazed by Japan in the 1990s. And Kobayashi contends (in classic Japanese passive voice) that America's dud assets are two to three times the size of Japan's at the time of its bust. Since the US economy (then) was roughly two times the size of Japan's and unlike them, we did not come into our mess with a large buffer of savings, the implication is that our problem is more severe than theirs. (...)
Go to the source
The Socialist Solution to the Crisis (Wall Street Journal - U.S.)
Thatcherism and Reaganism have failed on a momentous scale.
By POUL NYRUP RASMUSSEN president of the Party of European Socialists and a former prime minister of Denmark (1993-2001)
The job losses, repossessions, uncertainty, fear and misery faced by the people of Europe, the United States and Japan are a terrible stain on the consciences of those bankers and politicians whose doctrine of neo-liberal markets plunged us all into this crash. But the effect of the crisis on the Third World is of an entirely different magnitude. While developed countries scramble to save their economies, half of humanity languishes. For many, this means hunger, disease and death.
In Europe, we have been protected from the worst effects of the crisis thanks to welfare states built up over the past 60 years to cushion citizens from the threats posed by the free market. We can all count on state health care, social housing, education, unemployment support and other universal, tax-funded services.(...)
Go to the source
Geithner's Plan: Loopholes Galore (Business Week - U.S.)
Here are five ways hedge funds and investment banks may exploit Treasury's toxic-assets plan
By Theo Francis and Mara Der Hovanesian
It has been a little less than two weeks since Treasury Secretary Timothy F. Geithner unveiled the details of his project to restore banks to financial health. But analysts say hedge funds and investment banks are already looking for ways to exploit the complex web of auctions, public-private partnerships, and government guarantees proposed by Treasury to cleanse banks' books of toxic assets. "It's a highly gameable system," says H. Peyton Young, an Oxford University economist and a senior fellow at the Brookings Institution in Washington. "It's very difficult to write rules that are going to prevent self-dealing behavior."
Geithner's goal: entice investors to buy up the billions of dollars' worth of subprime mortgages, underwater commercial property loans, and other shaky securities that weigh down the banks' books. The partnerships will bid at auction for the dodgy parts of the banks' portfolios, hoping to get a big enough bargain that they can resell the assets later at a profit.(...)
Go to the source
The Quiet Coup (The Atlantic - U.S.)
By Simon Johnson
The crash has laid bare many unpleasant truths about the United States. One of the most alarming, says a former chief economist of the International Monetary Fund, is that the finance industry has effectively captured our government--a state of affairs that more typically describes emerging markets, and is at the center of many emerging-market crises. If the IMF's staff could speak freely about the U.S., it would tell us what it tells all countries in this situation: recovery will fail unless we break the financial oligarchy that is blocking essential reform. And if we are to prevent a true depression, we're running out of time.
ONE THING YOU learn rather quickly when working at the International Monetary Fund is that no one is ever very happy to see you. Typically, your "clients" come in only after private capital has abandoned them, after regional trading-bloc partners have been unable to throw a strong enough lifeline, after last-ditch attempts to borrow from powerful friends like China or the European Union have fallen through. You're never at the top of anyone's dance card.(...)
Go to the source
The G20 has lost the plot (The Telegraph - U.S.)
By Ambrose Evans-Pritchard
As we sit in this construction site in outer Docklands -- wondering what on earth the greatest concentration of world leaders in half a century must think of such a G20 venue, Saudi King Abdullah for instance - it is worth adding up the score in the stimulus war.
This is a not a fight between the US-UK on one side, and Europe on the other.
This the entire world on one side, and France-Germany on the other. (Why France is playing this bizarre role when social order is breaking down across the French industrial heartland at an alarming pace is a story in itself).(...)
Go to the source
Jump to the top